1900 Butler Tarkington Gem in Indianapolis, Indiana With Original Hardwood Floors, Deep Front Porches, and Refined Luxury
Situated in the prestigious and historic Butler Tarkington neighborhood of Indianapolis, this exquisitely renovated century home exemplifies early 20th-century American architectural elegance with its deep, welcoming front porches and Craftsman-inspired details. Priced at $1,250,000 and resting on a rare one-third acre lot, the home combines preserved original hardwood floors with a contemporary open-concept transformation that seamlessly joins the kitchen, dining, and family spaces. The luxurious main floor features a gourmet kitchen with dual dishwashers and a six-burner range, while the upper level boasts a refined primary suite and private balcony. Recent upgrades include a renovated detached garage with office space, sophisticated built-ins, and impeccably landscaped grounds, making this estate an icon of comfort and style.
Front Exterior
A stately two-story historic American home with gray horizontal siding and white trim. The symmetrical facade features four front-facing windows upstairs, complete with classic shutters, and a charming dormer window on the roof. A wide, inviting front porch stretches the length of the house, supported by sturdy white columns and furnished with a porch swing and wicker seating. Manicured shrubs line the porch, while seasonal pumpkins add a pop of color on one side. The driveway leads to a detached garage, and the lush green lawn is bordered by mature trees and neatly landscaped garden beds, creating a welcoming and timeless curb appeal.
Front Porch Exterior
An inviting two-story American home features a wide front porch supported by substantial square columns. The exterior is clad in muted grey-blue siding with deep blue shutters accenting the upper windows. A small, prominent dormer adds architectural interest to the roofline. Lush landscaping fills the foreground, with large, full hydrangea bushes crowned by creamy white blooms nestled below the porch. The yard has a neatly trimmed lawn bordered by dark mulched garden beds. Tall mature trees surround the house, offering a lush green backdrop and infusing the space with a tranquil, historic suburb feel.
Front Exterior
A stately two-story American home, painted a soft gray with white trim, stands behind a manicured lawn and a neat row of trimmed hedges. The symmetrical facade features shuttered windows and an extended covered porch supported by classic white columns. A smaller dormer sits atop the roof adding architectural interest. The porch wraps around, offering seating for relaxation and a welcoming entryway. Large trees provide shade, and a tall black metal fence encloses the side lawn. Bright sunlight highlights the green grass, while fallen leaves dot the yard, suggesting a pleasant, early autumn day in a tranquil neighborhood.
Front Porch Entryway
A charming front porch features a muted sage-green door adorned with an autumn-inspired wreath, framed by vertical windows and flanked by white trim. The number 33 is mounted in sleek silver beside a metal mailbox. The house siding is painted in a gentle gray-green, complemented by a dark wood ceiling above. To the right, a set of classic shutters frame the window, and beneath it sits a potted topiary in a black planter. A cozy porch swing, layered with pillows and a red throw, rests beside a circular woven rug, offering an inviting space surrounded by lush greenery and natural light.
Entryway Design
A welcoming entryway featuring a large, rustic wood front door with matching sidelight windows that allow natural light to filter in. The walls are painted a soft off-white, adorned with classic wainscoting and subtle panel molding. A neutral-toned area rug lies on the medium-tone wood flooring, enhancing the cozy ambiance. On one wall, a narrow floating wooden shelf holds a ceramic vase and decor, complemented by a large round mirror above it. Open archways and built-in shelving in nearby rooms contribute to a sense of openness and elegant continuity throughout the home.
Staircase Foyer
A wide foyer features a stately staircase with dark wooden steps and white risers, bordered by paneled white walls that create a sense of classic elegance. Natural light streams in from windows above, brightening the space. On the left, an arched doorway leads to a living room with a tan leather sofa, neutral cushions, and a gray accent wall. To the right, another arch opens toward a kitchen with white cabinetry and a breakfast bar with tall stools. The hardwood floors throughout the entry merge warm tones with the fresh white of the trim and walls, highlighting the home’s refined, welcoming ambiance.
Foyer and Parlor Entrance
Wide, paneled white walls set the stage in this foyer, defined by geometric trim that lends a sense of classic architectural detail. A wood floating shelf supports decorative objects beneath a large round mirror, which reflects the space and enhances light. The floor is warm-toned hardwood, partially covered by a light area rug, leading up a dark-wood staircase to the right. Through a graceful, arched doorway lies a sitting area with a dark accent wall, mid-century style chairs, a round wooden coffee table, and a large clock, creating a blend of historic elegance and modern comfort.
Living Room Details
A bright, cozy living room featuring a harmonious blend of modern and classic elements. A white-painted fireplace with a brick surround and an ornate mantel sits as the focal point, topped with a landscape painting in a gold frame. Flanking the fireplace are two small windows, allowing natural light to pour in. Warm tan leather and ivory upholstered armchairs encircle a rustic wooden coffee table with open shelving. The room is anchored by a patterned area rug in muted earthy tones, and a sleek black accent wall supports a large flat-screen television. Soft gray throw pillows add comfort and texture, enhancing the inviting ambiance.
Living Room Details
A bright, inviting living room features a warm and stylish blend of contemporary and traditional elements. The walls are painted a deep gray, setting off crisp white trim and molding for contrast. A large tan leather sofa sits against one wall, paired with cream armchairs and neutral-toned pillows, all arranged around a modern wood coffee table. Built-in white shelving flanks a set of windows, filled with books, baskets, and decorative pieces. An oversized industrial clock hangs above the couch, while large windows with plantation shutters allow soft natural light, enhancing the cozy and sophisticated atmosphere. A patterned rug adds texture and color underfoot.
Living Room Design
This space features a stylish living room with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The hardwood floors and crisp white crown molding create a historic yet contemporary feel. A striking black accent wall highlights a mounted flat-screen TV, while an elegant white mantel surrounds a brick fireplace, topped with a landscape painting in a gilded frame. The furniture includes a caramel leather sofa, two boucle swivel chairs, and a lounge chair with a wooden frame and woven back. A round wood coffee table sits atop a soft neutral rug, and large arched doorways lead into an adjacent dining area, showcasing the home’s classic architectural details.
Dining Area Details
A spacious dining area features a large wooden oval table surrounded by eight cushioned chairs, all in a light, warm wood tone. The table is set for fall with a centerpiece of pumpkins and two spiral candles. The space displays a modern-rustic aesthetic, highlighted by crisp white paneled walls and pale neutral curtains. Overhead hangs a striking black metal chandelier with four fabric shades, adding soft, ambient light. A decorative indoor tree in the corner brings in greenery. In the background, the dining area opens up to a cozy living space with neutral furniture, classic crown molding, and large windows letting in natural light.
Dining Room Table
A spacious dining room features a large oval wooden table surrounded by six matching wooden chairs with cushioned seats tied on with fabric bows. The table is decorated with an arrangement of neutral-colored pumpkins and candles, adding a seasonal or festive touch. Soft gray curtains frame a window with white plantation shutters, letting in gentle natural light. Paneled wainscoting and a subtle beige wall color create a classic, elegant backdrop. Overhead, a contemporary chandelier with simple white shades adds brightness. An arched doorway leads to another room, where a round mirror, small console table, and comfortable chair are visible, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere.
Living Room Details
A bright, cozy living room decorated in warm, neutral tones with a modern farmhouse aesthetic. Soft taupe walls and crisp white trim add brightness, complemented by a patterned rug featuring geometric shapes. The furniture includes a plush beige sectional, two wooden armchairs with deep blue upholstery and floral cushions, and a tan leather accent chair in one corner. The central coffee table has a round marble top with metal legs and holds a rustic vase filled with autumnal dried leaves. Glass French doors with wreaths, large windows, and white blinds allow plenty of natural light. A gray sideboard with glass doors supports a wall-mounted TV, while contemporary abstract art hangs nearby.
Kitchen Island Detail
A spacious kitchen features a large central island with a light grey countertop and dark cabinetry, surrounded by five woven-back barstools with black metal legs. The perimeter of the kitchen has white shaker cabinets, stainless steel hardware, and warm wood flooring underfoot. White subway tile walls create a classic backdrop, lit by two geometric pendant lights above the island. Large windows bring in natural light, with plants and decorative glass vessels adding subtle, organic touches. Stainless steel appliances and minimalist open shelving complete the modern, inviting atmosphere with a blend of traditional and contemporary design.
Kitchen Countertop
A bright, airy kitchen with a classic design features white cabinetry, marble countertops, and subway tile backsplash throughout. A large center island with dark cabinetry and polished marble surface dominates the foreground, adorned with a glass vase holding an arrangement of dried botanicals. Stainless steel appliances, including a gas stove and range hood, add a modern touch, while open shelves display glassware and subtle decor pieces. Natural light pours in from a window above the sink, complemented by elegant pendant lighting. Warm wood flooring grounds the space, creating a harmonious blend of historic charm and contemporary style.
Kitchen Island
A spacious kitchen with a large central island featuring a sturdy stone countertop and charcoal base. Four woven-seated barstools line one side for casual dining. Warm wooden floors balance the clean white cabinetry along the back wall. Two geometric pendant lights hang above the island, adding modern elegance. The backsplash is made of pale subway tiles, enhancing the room’s brightness. A stainless steel range hood is centered over the stove, with glass-fronted cabinets showcasing dishes nearby. At the side, a pair of wine coolers and a mosaic-tiled wall add visual interest, while natural light streams through a window.
Kitchen Countertop
Bright, airy kitchen features classic white cabinetry with simple paneling and chrome hardware. Warm natural light pours in through two large windows above the sleek marble countertops and under-mount sink. The white subway tile backsplash runs from counter to ceiling, creating a clean backdrop for the stainless steel gas stove and modern range hood. A tidy array of copper utensils, a knife block, glass canisters, and a potted plant add warmth and function to the space. The central island offers extra prep surface with its matching marble counter, and a woven stool tucked nearby hints at a cozy breakfast nook.
Mudroom Entryway
A bright and organized mudroom featuring a large glass-paneled door with white trim lets in natural light. Walls are covered in wide white shiplap, and the space is finished with blonde hardwood flooring. A built-in wooden bench with a natural wood surface runs along one side, providing seating and storage. Woven baskets sit underneath and above the bench in open cubbies and shelves, perfect for organizing shoes, bags, and accessories. Black hooks are mounted along the wall for hanging coats and purses. A patterned rug adds warmth and texture, while overhead recessed lighting keeps the area well-lit. The look is clean, functional, and welcoming.
Powder Room Sink
A small powder room with a pedestal sink features soft beige wallpaper and a classic white porcelain basin. Above the sink hangs a decorative mirror with a scalloped frame, reflecting a framed picture and a crystal chandelier that provides a touch of vintage elegance. A patterned hand towel hangs from a chrome ring on the left, and a bottle of soap sits on the right side of the sink alongside a small potted plant in a textured white pot. Natural light filters in, creating soft reflections on the walls, and enhancing the clean, serene atmosphere of this compact space.
Staircase Landing
Bright and welcoming staircase landing featuring classic white paneled walls with a grid pattern, offering a sense of historical charm and elegance. The staircase has dark-stained wooden railings and newel posts, paired with white painted balusters for a crisp contrasting effect. A built-in window seat below double windows invites natural light into the space, enhancing its airy feel. The hardwood floors add warmth and continuity, while the overall palette remains neutral and cohesive. Outdoor patio furniture is visible through the windows, suggesting a connection to an exterior living area. The architectural detailing reflects a timeless, traditional aesthetic.
Hallway Mirror
A bright hallway with creamy white walls and warm light wood floors, anchored by a large, minimalist rectangular mirror with arched corners at the end of the corridor. On the left, a wooden stool displays a large, textured ceramic vase filled with glossy, dark-leafed foliage. Wall-mounted candle sconces with gold accents and black candles add an elegant, vintage touch. Geometric area rugs in beige and brown soften the floor, with a subtle pattern adding visual interest. The hallway opens into another room, where an exercise bike and a modern wall-mounted TV are visible, creating a clean and organized transition space.
Primary Bedroom
A spacious bedroom filled with natural light from several large windows, featuring a plush, tufted headboard on the king-sized bed dressed in neutral brown bedding with an assortment of textured pillows. Matching wooden nightstands with modern ceramic lamps flank the bed. To the right, two large, dark-hued armchairs with accent pillows and a small side table create a cozy seating nook near framed artwork and another window. A light, neutral carpet covers the floor, and a sleek, modern chandelier hangs overhead. A stationary exercise bike is positioned in one corner, blending comfort with functionality. Soft, understated colors give the space an inviting, serene atmosphere.
Bedroom Seating Area
A spacious, sun-filled bedroom with a soft color palette of warm beige and crisp white. The plush bed anchors the left side, dressed in textured pillows and a neutral duvet. Two elegant, dark gray armchairs with patterned accent pillows sit by the windows, separated by a small black table with a vase. Floor-to-ceiling windows along the rear wall allow natural light to bathe the room. A leafy houseplant and a gallery wall of framed art add visual interest. The ceiling features crown molding and a dramatic black modern chandelier, while vintage-inspired dressers and a white secretary desk complete the welcoming look.
Bathroom and Closet
Elegant marble tiles cover the shower walls and floor area, lined with large rectangular slabs inside the shower and small hexagonal tiles outside. Glass shower doors, chrome fixtures, and a rainfall showerhead give a contemporary touch. To the right, a double vanity with gray cabinetry and marble countertop is accessorized with a large vase holding pampas grass, and wall-mounted lighting flanks generously sized mirrors. The color palette mixes soft grays, whites, and neutral taupe. Beyond the bathroom, double doors lead into a spacious walk-in closet, neatly organized with shelves full of shoes, accessories, and a bench under a sunlit window.
Bathroom Vanity
A symmetrical double-sink bathroom vanity with light grey cabinetry and marble countertops takes center stage. The wall above the vanity is a soft beige, and each sink has a rectangular, gold-framed mirror, with two frosted glass sconces mounted above for soft illumination. Central between the sinks, a tall glass vase with plumes of pampas grass adds a touch of organic elegance. Clear glass cabinet pulls and chrome fixtures provide a polished accent. Neatly rolled towels hang from chrome rings on each side, while subtle, neutral tones throughout create a calming and sophisticated space with a blend of modern and classic elements.
Upper Deck Seating
A cozy outdoor seating area on an elevated deck, featuring natural wood-toned flooring and surrounded by a crisp white metal railing. Two classic wicker chairs with plush gray and white checkered seat cushions flank a small round wicker table. A potted green plant sits atop the table, bringing a touch of nature to the space. Dappled sunlight filters through surrounding mature trees, casting striped shadows on the floor. The background reveals views of neighboring rooftops, garages, and lush greenery, with a vibrant mix of fall foliage accenting the serene and inviting atmosphere of this peaceful outdoor retreat.
Bedroom Accent Wall
A cozy bedroom features a dusty rose shiplap accent wall behind the bed, which is dressed in matching rose-colored linens and an assortment of plush pillows. Above the bed hangs a round, decorative mirror with a sunburst frame, adding a focal point. On one side of the bed sits a modern white three-drawer dresser with gold hardware, displaying a photo frame and a small decor piece. To the right, natural light streams in from a large window with white blinds, brightening the softly patterned area rug. The neutral walls, light wood flooring, and unique gold chandelier complete the room’s airy, serene ambiance.
Powder Room Vanity
A small, stylish powder room featuring soft cream and gray geometric wallpaper with an art-deco-inspired fan motif that wraps around the walls. The vanity has a white countertop with a gold-tone faucet and fixtures, and the cabinetry displays woven rattan panels, adding a touch of natural texture. There is a rectangular mirror with rounded edges framed in gold hanging above the sink. The toilet is tucked into the corner next to a piece of colorful floral wall art. The white basket-weave tile floor complements the overall neutral and light ambiance, giving the space an airy, elegant feel.
Bathroom Vanity Area
A classic bathroom with a blend of modern and historic elements. The bathtub and shower feature crisp white subway tiles with chrome fixtures, contrasted by the deep olive-green cabinetry. The cabinets are topped with a marble counter and brass faucet, illuminated by round, globe-style sconces beside a round brass-framed mirror. Hexagonal mosaic floor tiles add vintage elegance, while two narrow windows framed in green provide natural light. Decorative baskets and potted plants give the space a touch of coziness, and built-in cubbies store towels and essentials neatly. The overall color palette includes white, green, brass, and natural stone.
Driveway and Garage
Expansive concrete driveway leading to a detached garage with white carriage-style doors accented by black handles and upper window panels. A basketball hoop is positioned at the edge of the driveway, casting a prominent shadow across the sunlit pavement. The house exterior features soft gray horizontal siding with crisp white trim, and a potted plant sits near a short step leading to the entrance. Lush, mature trees and a green lawn provide a natural backdrop, while the neighboring yards are enclosed by fencing, adding privacy and a sense of calm suburban space. The overall atmosphere is welcoming and spacious.
Home Office Corner
A warm, functional workspace features hardwood floors and muted beige walls, illuminated by natural light from two large windows dressed with simple rattan blinds. A modern desk with a sleek office chair sits to the right, facing a computer monitor, with small plants adding a touch of greenery. A tan leather sofa along the opposite wall provides a cozy place to relax, draped with a white throw. Above the sofa, a large glass whiteboard offers space for notes. The left wall has a mounted bicycle and TV, while a rustic wood cabinet and drawers suggest a blend of vintage and contemporary style.
Covered Patio Dining
A spacious covered patio features rustic charm with a long, raw wood dining table and matching benches centered on durable stone-tiled flooring. The ceiling is dark stained wood with recessed lighting and two black ceiling fans, adding a touch of modern comfort. White posts frame the open-air view of a leafy, green and gold backyard, surrounded by ornamental black fencing. A side buffet or countertop stands near the house’s shiplap siding, complemented by lantern-style sconces. At the far end, outdoor lounges and a television suggest a versatile space for casual gatherings and relaxing. Warm autumn colors enhance the inviting, cozy atmosphere.
Backyard Lawn
A spacious and well-kept backyard with lush green grass covers most of the ground, scattered here and there with fallen leaves hinting at early autumn. Tall mature trees stand throughout, providing ample shade and a sense of privacy for the area. To one side, a black metal fence separates the yard from neighboring properties. Visible in the background are a small detached outbuilding or garage painted white and another light-colored structure, both with simple gabled roofs. A barbecue grill sits near the covered porch, and swings hang from a tree, lending a family-friendly and relaxed atmosphere to the outdoor space.
Backyard Patio
The backyard features a covered patio area extending from the rear of a two-story house, supported by white square columns. A cozy sitting space with a sectional sofa is set to one side, and a long wooden dining table with benches sits in the middle. The siding of the house is a soft taupe-gray with crisp white trim and a French door leading inside. A grill stands nearby, surrounded by simple landscaping with low bushes and a neat garden bed. The yard is expansive and grassy, bordered by mature trees and a detached, double-door garage finished in matching tones.
Backyard Entrance
A wide concrete driveway leads to the rear entrance of a two-story historic American home. The exterior features light gray horizontal siding contrasted by white trim around multiple windows and a prominent red brick chimney. Steps ascend to a small covered porch with black metal railings and potted plants, creating a welcoming yet functional entryway. To the left, a spacious green lawn with mature trees provides ample natural shade, while garden beds line the home’s foundation. The bright, sunny sky highlights the clean lines and classic appeal of this well-maintained property.
Listing Agent: Matt McLaughlin of F.C. Tucker Company via Zillow
